Skip to content
Monday, 16 November 2026
Back to Front Page
News 5 min read

Landlord Sums Tribunal Rent Study Reveals 70% Of Rent Increases Are Cut As Tenants Challenge Landlords

Olivia Published By Olivia

Published:

Updated:

Share:
Landlord Sums Tribunal Rent Study Reveals 70% Of Rent Increases Are Cut As Tenants Challenge Landlords
Leaflet Index

Table of Contents

Published: 3 November 2026

Landlords across England are facing growing resistance to proposed rent increases, with a new study revealing that 70% of challenged rent rises have been reduced by property tribunals since May 2026.

The findings, published by property finance platform Landlord Sums, suggest that tenants are increasingly successful in securing lower increases than landlords initially demand, following changes introduced under the Renters’ Rights Act.

The research examined 668 First-tier Tribunal market rent decisions made since 1 May 2026. It found that landlords typically requested rent increases of 13.9%, but tribunals allowed a median rise of just 7.7%.

The difference highlights the growing importance of local rental evidence when landlords seek higher payments, particularly as property owners prepare for additional tax pressures following the October 2026 Budget.

According to the study, 55% of cases resulted in a rent increase smaller than the landlord requested, while approximately 10% ended with rents remaining unchanged.

In another 4% of cases, tribunals reduced the rent below what tenants were already paying.

However, the findings do not suggest that most tenants can avoid increases altogether. The majority of challenged cases still resulted in higher rents, even where the tribunal rejected part of the landlord’s proposal.

London Landlords Face Significant Cuts to Proposed Rent Increases

London emerged as one of the areas where landlords were seeking the largest increases.

Analysis of 208 tribunal decisions in the capital showed that landlords typically requested increases of 16.7%, while tribunals determined a median increase of 9.5%.

Approximately 66% of proposed increases were reduced.

The figures are particularly significant for London households already facing substantial housing costs.

In one tribunal case involving a two-bedroom flat at Windward Court in east London, the landlord sought to increase monthly rent from £2,050 to £2,350.

However, the tribunal determined that the rent should remain at £2,050, rejecting the proposed £300 monthly increase.

Another case involving a three-bedroom flat in Abbey Grove, south-east London, saw a proposed increase from £1,900 to £2,200 reduced to £2,100.

These decisions demonstrate how tribunals assess individual properties rather than automatically accepting the amount requested by a landlord.

Rental comparisons, accommodation standards, property condition, and local market evidence can all influence the outcome.

The findings also come as London’s wider rental market continues to experience price increases.

According to the Office for National Statistics, average private rents in London rose by 3.5% in the 12 months to September 2026. England recorded annual rental inflation of 4%.

These official figures measure the wider rental market and are not directly comparable with increases sought in individual tribunal disputes.

Across other English regions, the Landlord Sums research found that tribunals reduced approximately 76% of challenged proposals in the South, 74% in the East of England, 72% in the Midlands and 67% in the North.

Rent Tribunal Cases Surge Following New Tenant Protections

The research also points to a significant increase in the number of rent disputes reaching tribunal decisions.

Between January 2025 and April 2026, an average of approximately 48 market rent decisions were recorded each month.

That figure increased to around 165 monthly decisions between May and September 2026, with September recording approximately 194 decisions in the study.

The rise follows major changes to England’s private rental sector under the Renters’ Rights Act, which came into effect on 1 May 2026.

Under the new rules, landlords generally must use the statutory Section 13 procedure to increase rent, providing tenants with at least two months’ notice through Form 4A.

Landlords cannot increase rent more than once a year, and tenants can challenge proposed increases that exceed the property’s open-market rental value.

Importantly, for increases governed by the new rules, a tribunal cannot determine a rent higher than the amount the landlord proposed.

This reduces one of the financial risks previously associated with challenging a rent increase.

Property lawyer David Smith, a partner at Bishop & Sewell, examined an earlier, smaller group of tribunal decisions in September.

His assessment found that tribunals were generally granting landlords much of what they requested, although outcomes varied considerably.

Smith wrote that tribunals were “giving landlords most of what they asked for, but they are not being generous.”

That earlier analysis involved notices served after the new rules began, whereas the larger Landlord Sums study groups cases by decision date. Some of the latter cases may therefore involve notices issued before May.

The distinction matters when measuring the precise impact of the new legislation.

Further evidence published by mortgage advisory firm Cyborg Finance on 1 November reinforced the wider finding that full rent increases are frequently rejected.

Its separate examination of 74 September tribunal decisions found that only 28.4% of landlords received their full requested increase. Another 39.2% received a partial increase.

Mark Hosker, mortgage adviser at Cyborg Finance, said:

“Landlords should be ready to support proposed rents with comparable local evidence.”

He also cautioned that challenging a rent increase does not necessarily mean tenants will avoid paying more.

Tenant Rent Tribunal Hearing

Higher Landlord Taxes Add Pressure to the Rental Market

The tribunal findings arrive just days after the government’s October Budget confirmed further increases to income tax on property earnings.

From 6 April 2027, the proposed property income tax rates will be 24% for basic-rate taxpayers, 44% for higher-rate taxpayers and 49% for additional-rate taxpayers in England, Wales and Northern Ireland.

The higher tax burden could encourage some landlords to reassess rental income, property expenses and the financial viability of their investments.

However, increased taxation does not automatically justify raising rents beyond local market levels.

Tribunals focus on the market rental value of the property rather than simply the amount a landlord needs to cover mortgage payments, maintenance expenses or tax liabilities.

The Landlord Sums research also found that larger requested increases were particularly vulnerable to reductions.

Among proposed increases of between 15% and 25%, approximately 82% were reduced. For requests exceeding 50%, the proportion reached 88%.

This suggests landlords proposing substantial increases face a greater risk of receiving a lower determination, especially where the proposed figure cannot be supported by comparable rental properties.

For tenants, the findings show that challenging a rent rise can make a meaningful financial difference, but the outcome remains dependent on the evidence presented.

Landlords who can demonstrate that their proposed rent reflects similar properties in the same area may still secure an increase.

As more tenants become aware of their rights, England’s rental tribunals could remain an increasingly important part of the housing market.

The findings carry one important limitation: they cover cases that reached the tribunal, not every rent increase imposed across England.

They therefore cannot establish how frequently landlords’ proposals are challenged or reduced across the rental sector as a whole.

Nevertheless, the latest figures suggest that the balance in disputed rental negotiations is changing, with landlords facing greater scrutiny over whether their proposed increases genuinely reflect market conditions.

Olivia

About the Journalist

OliviaNews Editor

Olivia covers London life, culture and lifestyle for Londoner. Her work includes food, shopping, neighbourhood trends, attractions, local experiences and practical guides for residents and visitors. She focuses on engaging stories that reflect everyday life across the capital.

Follow:

Reader Discussion (0)

Add your perspective

Keep comments relevant, respectful and factual.

Related Stories

More from this section